A meeting between officials from the U.S. Department of Defense and the Vatican has drawn scrutiny after sharply conflicting accounts emerged, raising questions about diplomatic tensions between Washington and the Holy See during an escalating global crisis.
According to a source close to Pope Leo XIV, the meeting involving Cardinal Christophe Pierre was described as confrontational. Separate reports characterized the exchange as a stern warning emphasizing U.S. military strength and urging alignment with American policy. However, Pentagon officials strongly disputed that portrayal, stating the discussion was respectful and constructive, underscoring a commitment to continued dialogue with the Vatican.
Adding to the conflicting narratives, Vatican ambassador Brian Burch stated on Thursday that Cardinal Pierre rejected media reports describing the meeting as hostile, calling them fabricated. He said the meeting, which occurred two months earlier, was “frank and cordial,” suggesting that accounts of tension may have been overstated.
The dispute comes amid increasingly pointed remarks from Pope Leo XIV, the first U.S.-born pontiff from Chicago, who has taken an unusually direct stance on the ongoing conflict involving Iran. On Tuesday, the pope criticized U.S. President Donald Trump’s warning of severe consequences for Iran, calling such rhetoric “truly unacceptable” and warning that attacks on civilian infrastructure violate international law.
In recent appeals, Leo has urged global leaders and citizens to pursue peace and avoid further escalation, particularly in a conflict he described as unjust and destabilizing. He also encouraged individuals to contact political leaders and advocate against actions targeting civilians, emphasizing the moral and legal implications of such strategies.
The Vatican’s concerns extend beyond Iran, particularly to Lebanon, where renewed fighting involving Israeli forces and Hezbollah has intensified instability. Church officials have expressed alarm over the impact on Christian communities in southern Lebanon, which hold significant importance for the region’s religious presence.
The broader geopolitical situation remains fragile. A ceasefire related to the Iran conflict appeared uncertain after Iran moved to close the Strait of Hormuz following Israeli strikes in Lebanon, prompting renewed calls from the White House to maintain open waterways and continue peace negotiations.
While both the Pentagon and Vatican have emphasized the importance of ongoing dialogue, the divergence in accounts surrounding their recent meeting highlights the complexity of diplomatic relations during a period of heightened global tension.
